When a potential customer asks for your company’s SOC report, you may not know exactly what they’re looking for. Maybe their procurement team wants a SOC 2 report before signing a contract. Maybe their finance department needs assurance that your processes won’t affect their financial reporting.
Either way, you’re left with an important question: Do you need a SOC 1 or SOC 2 report?
The two reports serve different purposes, and choosing the right one depends on the services your business provides, the information you handle and what your customers need to see.
At Holbrook & Manter, our team works with organizations to navigate SOC examinations, understand their reporting requirements and prepare for the process. Through our risk advisory services, we help businesses evaluate their internal controls, address compliance needs and build stronger processes. Here’s what you should know about SOC 1 vs. SOC 2 and how to determine which report makes sense for your business.
SOC 1 vs. SOC 2: What’s the Difference?
The biggest difference between SOC 1 and SOC 2 comes down to the types of controls being evaluated and the risks those controls address.
What Is a SOC 1 Report?
A SOC 1 report evaluates controls at a service organization that are relevant to its customers’ internal control over financial reporting.
In other words, if your business provides services that could affect how another company handles or reports its financial information, a SOC 1 examination may be appropriate.
Common examples include:
- Payroll processing companies that calculate employee wages and manage payroll data.
- Billing and payment processing providers that handle financial transactions.
- Claims processing companies that manage insurance claims.
- Outsourced accounting and financial service providers.
- Organizations that maintain systems used to process financial information for their clients.
A SOC 1 report helps your customers and their external auditors understand whether the controls relevant to financial reporting are appropriately designed and, for a Type 2 report, operating effectively.
It’s also important to understand that a SOC 1 report and SOX compliance are not the same thing. While both involve internal controls over financial reporting, they serve different purposes. Businesses looking for guidance on broader financial reporting controls may also benefit from exploring Holbrook & Manter’s SOX Compliance services.
What Is a SOC 2 Report?
A SOC 2 report focuses on an organization’s controls related to security, data protection and other areas of its technology environment.
These examinations follow the AICPA’s Trust Services Criteria, which cover five categories:
- Security: Protecting systems and information against unauthorized access.
- Availability: Making sure systems and services are available as agreed.
- Processing Integrity: Ensuring systems process information accurately, completely and as intended.
- Confidentiality: Protecting information designated as confidential.
- Privacy: Addressing how personal information is collected, used, retained, disclosed and disposed of.
Security is included in every SOC 2 examination. The remaining categories are included based on the organization’s services, commitments and reporting objectives.
SOC 2 reports are especially common among businesses that store, process or manage customer information, including:
- Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) companies.
- Managed IT and technology service providers.
- Cloud hosting and data center providers.
- Healthcare technology companies.
- Financial technology providers.
Customers typically use SOC 2 reports to evaluate whether a vendor has appropriate controls in place to protect their information and support its services.
A quick way to remember the difference: SOC 1 focuses on controls relevant to financial reporting. SOC 2 focuses on controls related to security and the handling of customer information.
Some organizations may need both, depending on the services they provide.
For a closer look at how these reports help businesses establish trust with customers and partners, read Holbrook & Manter’s article on Providing Assurance Through SOC Reports.
SOC 1 vs. SOC 2: Which Report Does Your Business Need?
Choosing between SOC 1 and SOC 2 isn’t necessarily about which report is better. It’s about understanding what your customers need assurance over.
A SOC 1 report may be the right fit if your services affect your customers’ financial reporting. A SOC 2 report may be more appropriate if your business handles sensitive information, operates technology systems or provides services that require customers to trust your security practices.
Consider these questions before deciding:
- Does your business process financial transactions or information that affects your customers’ financial statements?
- Do you store or process customer data?
- Are customers asking about your information security practices?
- Does a vendor questionnaire specifically request a SOC 1 or SOC 2 report?
- Are you entering contracts with customers that require independent assurance over your controls?
It’s also worth knowing that SOC 2 is not a universal legal requirement for every business. However, customers, industry expectations and contractual obligations can make it an important part of doing business.
If you’re unsure which examination applies, reviewing the specific requests from your customers is a good place to start. Your CPA firm can also help evaluate the services you provide and determine the appropriate reporting approach.
SOC 1 and SOC 2: Understanding Type 1 vs. Type 2 Reports
Once you’ve determined whether you need a SOC 1 or SOC 2 report, there’s another decision to make: Type 1 or Type 2?
Both report types evaluate an organization’s controls, but they differ in how and when those controls are assessed.
SOC Type 1 Report
A Type 1 report evaluates whether an organization’s controls are suitably designed and implemented as of a specific date.
It provides a snapshot of the organization’s control environment at that point in time. Because it doesn’t evaluate how consistently those controls operated over an extended period, it may be a practical starting point for organizations pursuing their first SOC examination.
SOC Type 2 Report
A Type 2 report goes a step further. In addition to evaluating the design of controls, it examines whether those controls operated effectively over a specified period, typically three to twelve months.
The auditor reviews supporting documentation, selects samples and tests whether the organization’s controls functioned as intended throughout the examination period.
Many customers prefer or specifically request a Type 2 report because it provides evidence of how controls performed over time rather than just how they were designed on a particular date.
Do you need a Type 1 before getting a Type 2?
Not necessarily. A business can pursue a Type 2 examination without first obtaining a Type 1 report. The right approach depends on the organization’s readiness, customer requirements and ability to demonstrate that its controls have been operating effectively throughout the review period.
What About SOC 3?
SOC 3 is another reporting option worth understanding.
Like SOC 2, a SOC 3 report addresses controls related to the Trust Services Criteria. However, it contains less detail about the organization’s systems and the auditor’s testing procedures.
One of the biggest differences is how the reports can be shared. SOC 2 reports are intended for restricted-use audiences, such as customers and business partners. SOC 3 reports are designed for general use and can be distributed more broadly.
For businesses that want to demonstrate their commitment to security and controls without sharing the detailed information included in a SOC 2 report, SOC 3 may be worth considering.
The appropriate report depends on what your customers expect and what your organization wants to demonstrate.
What Does a SOC Audit Involve?
Whether you’re pursuing a SOC 1 or SOC 2 report, the examination process involves several steps. Understanding what’s involved can help your team prepare, avoid unnecessary delays and establish realistic expectations.
Here’s what the process generally looks like:
1. Scoping the Examination
The first step is determining which report your business needs and what will be included in the examination. This involves identifying relevant systems, services, locations, vendors and applicable criteria.
Getting the scope right from the beginning helps prevent unnecessary work and ensures the report addresses the areas your customers need to evaluate.
2. Completing a Readiness Assessment
Before formal testing begins, a readiness assessment can help identify gaps between your existing controls and the applicable reporting criteria.
This step isn’t required for every engagement, but it can be especially helpful for organizations pursuing their first SOC report.
3. Addressing Control Gaps
Once potential gaps are identified, your team can work on addressing them.
Depending on your business, this might include formalizing security policies, documenting employee access reviews, improving system monitoring or establishing clearer approval procedures.
The goal is to make sure your controls are not only documented but also consistently followed.
4. Auditor Testing and Fieldwork
During fieldwork, the auditor evaluates the organization’s controls based on the type of examination.
For a Type 1 report, the focus is on the design and implementation of controls as of a specific date. For a Type 2 report, the auditor also tests operating effectiveness using evidence collected throughout the review period.
5. Receiving the Final Report
After testing is complete, the CPA firm prepares the SOC report.
The report generally includes the independent service auditor’s opinion, management’s description of the system and, for a Type 2 examination, the auditor’s testing procedures and results.
The finished report can then be shared with the appropriate customers and business partners.
Organizations that need additional guidance throughout this process can explore Holbrook & Manter’s SOC Audit Services to learn more about the firm’s SOC examination, planning and reporting support.
What Can Delay Your First SOC 2 Examination?
For organizations pursuing their first SOC 2 report, preparation can make a significant difference.
Some of the most common issues that create delays include:
- Incomplete or outdated policies. Your written policies should reflect how your organization actually operates.
- Missing documentation. If employee access reviews, system changes or approvals aren’t documented, it can be difficult to provide the evidence an auditor needs.
- Unaddressed vendor relationships. Third-party providers and cloud services may need to be considered when determining the scope of your examination.
- Unclear reporting requirements. Including unnecessary systems or criteria can make the process more complicated than it needs to be.
- Starting a Type 2 examination too early. Controls need to be implemented and operating before the review period begins.
Taking the time to prepare can help your organization approach the examination with fewer surprises.
Can Compliance Software Issue a SOC Report?
Compliance automation software can be a helpful part of the SOC preparation process. These platforms can organize documentation, collect evidence, monitor certain controls and help teams track their progress.
However, compliance software and a SOC examination are two different things.
A SOC report is an independent attestation examination performed by a qualified CPA firm under applicable professional standards. Software can help your organization prepare, but it cannot replace the independent auditor’s evaluation or issue the auditor’s opinion.
When evaluating compliance platforms, make sure you understand which services are included, whether an independent CPA firm is involved and who will actually perform the examination and issue the report.
Frequently Asked Questions About SOC 1 and SOC 2
How long does it take to get a SOC 2 report?
The timeline depends on your organization’s existing controls, documentation and readiness. A Type 2 examination also requires an observation period, typically three to twelve months. Preparation and remediation can add time before that period begins, so organizations should plan ahead.
How often does a business need a SOC 2 report?
Many organizations obtain updated SOC 2 reports annually to provide customers with current information about their control environment. Specific customer contracts and reporting expectations may determine how frequently an updated report is needed.
Can a company have both a SOC 1 and SOC 2 report?
Yes. Some organizations provide services that affect customers’ financial reporting while also handling sensitive information or operating technology systems. In those situations, both reports may be appropriate because they address different types of controls.
Is a SOC 2 report a certification?
No. A SOC 2 report is the result of an independent examination performed by a CPA firm. It provides an opinion on the organization’s controls rather than a certification that the business is compliant with every security or privacy requirement.
Is a SOC 2 report required by law?
Generally, there is no universal law requiring every business to obtain a SOC 2 report. However, customers, contracts, industry expectations and vendor requirements may make one necessary to maintain or secure business relationships.
Find the Right SOC Reporting Approach for Your Business
Choosing between SOC 1, SOC 2 and SOC 3 is an important decision, particularly when customer expectations and business relationships are involved.
The right approach starts with understanding the services you provide, the controls that matter to your customers and the type of assurance they need.
Holbrook & Manter works with organizations to plan and navigate SOC examinations, from determining the appropriate report to completing the reporting process. Whether you’re preparing for your first SOC 2 examination or need guidance on an existing SOC reporting program, our team can help you understand what’s involved.
Learn more about Holbrook & Manter’s SOC audit services and how we support businesses through the process.
Ready to discuss your SOC reporting needs? Contact Holbrook & Manter to get started.